CineMaterial logo

Development - Moderators reviewing images - THIS IS A PROBLEM

monroville User

Written at 14 Aug 2023 on 21:31

I have images that date back to May 30th. I have provided web links to verify their legitimacy to no avail. I have had images deleted regardless of rules, after sitting in my PENDING folder for over a month.

If an image fits the parameters of the site, why does it take more than 7 to 10 days for a review and a decision to make? If there are problems, why not contact the user to help them? Why does it feel as if things become personal to the point where you can no longer contribute to the site because of some vendetta?

I cannot tell you how many times a moderator has approved ONE IMAGE while ignoring the rest. If the image is bad, delete it. If it fits the parameters, accept it. If you have the time to review ONE image, then by all that is Holy, please review the rest.

Also, does the PM section not work? I have sent countless messages to "Contact Us" without any replies or responses. I know it takes time to read messages, but to ignore someone for over a month?

Do you want people to contribute to site or not?
monroville User

Written at 31 Aug 2023 on 18:27 Edited at 13 Jan 2024 on 00:25

[issue taken care of]
monroville User

Written at 03 Sep 2023 on 21:21 Edited at 13 Jan 2024 on 00:26

[issue taken care of]
monroville User

Written at 13 Jan 2024 on 00:20 Edited at 18 Feb 2024 on 05:35

I want to say "Thank You" for whoever is reviewing my images on a fairly timely basis. I do appreciate that.

I am wondering why phenomena-i87909/p/uizfeqkk was deleted, as I color corrected and repaired the poster damage/fold lines for phenomena-i87909/p/0ngj1ux8.
monroville User

Written at 13 Jan 2024 on 23:51 Edited at 08 Mar 2024 on 05:35

I will say "Thank you" to whoever reviewed my images. I do appreciate it.
monroville User

Written at 01 Mar 2024 on 02:36 Edited at 19 Mar 2024 on 01:05

I was wondering if a moderator could review these images as to why they were deleted:

Spermula Carlotta blu-ray release:
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/spermula-i75251/p/h13wepze

Messalina and Caligula - Italian poster - fixed poster damage and fold lines:
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/caligula-et-messaline-i83710/p/kjwnmd86
monroville User

Written at 13 Apr 2024 on 20:33 Edited at 19 Apr 2024 on 20:08

[I meant to EDIT this with the message below, to keep the thread as clean as possible]
monroville User

Written at 19 Apr 2024 on 19:55 Edited at 19 Apr 2024 on 20:13

I appreciate someone going through all of my images. I have a few questions:

Why were these rejected, as they are legitimate DVD and poster images:
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/quella-villa-accanto-al-cimitero-i82966/p/pgvuhifd
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/quella-villa-accanto-al-cimitero-i82966/p/xvg0krxr

you include double feature artwork on the site.

and this (https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/zombi-2-i80057/p/zgkrrhjg) is a larger and cleaner alternative version of this (https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/zombi-2-i80057/p/jtwfoc5y)

and this image (https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/the-fly-i91064/p/hh08vidk) is an upgrade for a pre-existing image (more image on top and better colors) (https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/the-fly-i91064/p/je6wxuh6)

just wondering if someone could review these.
monroville User

Written at 30 Apr 2024 on 19:21

Here we go again!

Why is a moderator rejecting images without explanation, or images that have been approved for other movies (fixed poster fold lines/damage; improved color/contrast/color timing)? Why are moderators rejecting one or two images but not reviewing the rest of my images? Why does this keep happening and what does it take to get a moderator to PM me about any of this?

Re: https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/drop-out-i67019/p/qv2crha0 compared to https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/drop-out-i67019/p/54jcjgvf

You have accepted posters that I have repaired/fixed poster damage/folds before, so why is this getting an instant rejection? Is this someone's personal image that they don't want replaced?

Why is https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/profondo-rosso-i73582/p/9jlxxcdx being rejected when you have accepted plenty of art created by Silver Ferox:

https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/inferno-i80923/p/4vgkmhej
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/inferno-i80923/p/te0dffbx
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/phenomena-i87909/p/kxnzdr2v
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/phenomena-i87909/p/allkap0y

Why is this a constant issue? Why is the mod judgement all over the place? Sometimes I get get images reviewed in less than 3 days.. other times to takes 30 days or more. IS it a personal thing? Also, I wouldn't have to post any of this drama in the forum if anyone would reply when I use "Contact us" on the bottom of the page.