CineMaterial logo

General - Rejected?

micio684 User

Written at 19 Feb 2022 on 21:40

lmaq wrote:
This is because the other user upload it first. As usual.

It is not always as you say. To give an example, these were deleted from me and then reappeared by another user:
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/the-unbearable-weight-of-massive-talent-i11291274/p/lwdlhbna
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/goliath-i13399946/p/msgxlaqx
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/les-amours-danais-i13142240/p/ziudmdhw
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/naomi-i13624900/p/8hdjko4n
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/rogue-hostage-i13067292/p/cgkx89wu

It is right that there are rules, and a reason must be given as to why they are approved first and then eliminated.
an example: https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/panama-i4029412/p/v11bdxm5
massy Editor

Written at 20 Feb 2022 on 04:26 Edited at 20 Feb 2022 on 04:27

Hi Micio...

That Panama image is NOT an original textless. I wouldn't upload it if I were you. People don't spend credits here to download non-original or badly removed text from covers to make them textless artworks... it is not fair.

Many of your uploads which are original are great though, please keep them up! Thank you.
micio684 User

Written at 20 Feb 2022 on 09:33

massy wrote:
Hi Micio...

That Panama image is NOT an original textless. I wouldn't upload it if I were you. People don't spend credits here to download non-original or badly removed text from covers to make them textless artworks... it is not fair.

Many of your uploads which are original are great though, please keep them up! Thank you.


Hi Massy :-) thanks for the reply
Congratulations on your awesome, textless image gallery!
You're right Panama isn't original textless but I don't fully agree that users spend credits for original textless. Many users, many users, no matter whether it is original or not, the important thing is that it is done well.
This textless (https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/the-dropout-i10166622/p/dl9kb4bo) is not original, but it has been approved, but it is my creation and I always try to do great work and it costs me too several hours of work.
Also this textless (https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/no-exit-i7550014/p/restenkj5h) is my creation and is perfect but has been rejected.
instead this image (https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/here-before-i8649190/p/fkb0nsim) instead is original and has been deleted.
As you can see it is difficult to recognize an original from a custom, but I repeat myself, users are not just looking for original textless, and they don't always exist and I create them for them. I repeat myself, I do it for passion and they cost me several hours of work and the important thing is that it is done well that is comparable to an original.
micio684 User

Written at 20 Feb 2022 on 09:45

massy wrote:
Hi Micio...

That Panama image is NOT an original textless. I wouldn't upload it if I were you. People don't spend credits here to download non-original or badly removed text from covers to make them textless artworks... it is not fair.

Many of your uploads which are original are great though, please keep them up! Thank you.


Massy.
to give you another example, these are all original:
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/power-book-iv-force-i11761194/p/pwacb0j1
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/legacy-of-love-i12933568/p/fdnwnkon
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/from-i9813792/p/atbufiux
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/from-i9813792/p/icxdhhxw
and have been canceled. I do not understand what the moderator is based on the choice of images.
micio684 User

Written at 10 Mar 2022 on 06:50

why were they rejected? motivation.
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/pieces-of-her-i9170236/p/foi01lrl
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/the-last-mark-i12773826/p/vuuaj7ym
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/val-i14731254/p/g3jqmczj
micio684 User

Written at 28 Apr 2022 on 19:23

Sorry, but why were they canceled? are they original poster and textless? the cancellation makes no sense !!! but do you delete at random or do you have a reason?
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/the-black-phone-i7144666/p/iimi3vok
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/the-black-phone-i7144666/p/nb5ktkje
micio684 User

Written at 30 Apr 2022 on 08:18

Nooo !!! once again have you deleted this textless?
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/the-black-phone-i7144666/p/iimi3vok
Do you approve it, delete it, approve it and delete it ... this is a original textless !!!!!!!!!!!!
micio684 User

Written at 07 May 2022 on 08:54

Who after 3 months has deleted my texless?
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/the-dropout-i10166622/p/dl9kb4bo
After three months it is no longer original ??? ... there is something wrong with you moderators! I have no more words, how sad!
micio684 User

Written at 07 Jul 2022 on 05:47

https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/suitcase-killer-the-melanie-mcguire-story-i19813094/p/gb0frg1k
Reason for refusal?
micio684 User

Written at 09 Jul 2022 on 19:45

Hello.
I have deleted this poster ( https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/happily-never-after-i16154794/p/ap6zftzo ) _ (2159 * 3155 pixels, 4496 kb) because one already exists, but by di low quality (1480 * 2162 pixels, 387 kb), is this normal?
Why this original poster was deleted: https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/i-know-what-you-did-last-summer-i10937180/p/ezvbflss
motivation, thanks
lmaq Moderator

Written at 09 Jul 2022 on 20:50

https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/happily-never-after-i16154794/p/ap6zftzo. Your poster is inflated
micio684 User

Written at 10 Jul 2022 on 10:25

lmaq wrote:
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/happily-never-after-i16154794/p/ap6zftzo. Your poster is inflated

Ok, but I haven't done any inflation. I just added the bass part that was missing.
Delete.
micio684 User

Written at 01 Aug 2022 on 17:34

Hello.
This image has been deleted:
https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/the-immaculate-room-i13698942/p/wwnhwcuy
This is original textless!
micio684 User

Written at 28 Oct 2022 on 05:52

Sorry.
But why was this poster deleted? motivation?
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/wecrashed-i12005128/p/hht7yn03
micio684 User

Written at 21 Nov 2022 on 06:59

Why were these images deleted?
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/the-english-i11771270/p/xzls9kno
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/the-english-i11771270/p/mwfnkbyi
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/national-treasure-edge-of-history-i12580982/p/djwywkz1
Motivation, thank you
Ashirg Moderator

Written at 21 Nov 2022 on 20:28

I wasn't the moderator, but National Treasure has wrong country. You can re-submit with correct country.
Both of The English posters have higher resolution uploads yesterday -
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/the-english-i11771270/p/feu3tpz2
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/the-english-i11771270/p/hxnqf3o4
micio684 User

Written at 21 Nov 2022 on 20:42

Ashirg wrote:
I wasn't the moderator, but National Treasure has wrong country. You can re-submit with correct country.
Both of The English posters have higher resolution uploads yesterday -
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/the-english-i11771270/p/feu3tpz2
https://www.cinematerial.com/tv/the-english-i11771270/p/hxnqf3o4

Okay. Thanks for the reply.
micio684 User

Written at 11 Jan 2023 on 06:47

I don't understand why my textless was deleted? https://www.cinematerial.com/movies/fall-i15325794/p/x9v3yu8k
massy Editor

Written at 18 Jan 2023 on 05:26 Edited at 18 Jan 2023 on 07:28

Hey Micio
Your questions are to be answered by mods, if they find it necessary. We all know they have one of the hardest jobs of the world where they have to check and deal with hundreds of images daily! Kudos to them. So, I'm merely here to help as a friend if I could.

In this particular case, when an uncropped/less-cropped [more art on the edges of image] and higher resolution of an "exact same artwork" is uploaded, the previous one gets deleted. (the rules on posters, covers etc are slightly different, I'm not sure. It's up to mods to decide.)

This relates to one of the major and known rules of the site for uploading too: "Only upload images of posters we already have when the quality is significantly higher". So, once a superior one is taken, the older one is deleted in most cases.
Tens of my uploads have been deleted according to this rule, which is understandable. It's a RULE.

Again, this is not my place to give you an official answer, I just try to share what I've learned during these years of uploading covers, posters and artworks here. I could be wrong nevertheless.

Oh, I just read your other post. I agree with you that many members might be looking for done-well non-original artworks as well as originals, but there are site rules that we should consider too and as far as I know custom artworks are NOT accepted here unless they are done well, really well! Which of course is up to mods to decide again...
micio684 User

Written at 18 Jan 2023 on 07:34

Hi Massy.
I'm glad to hear from you, and I understand the rules that exist on the site and must be respected, ok. I know the work that moderators do very well, I have a cover site, I'm the admin and I know how much effort it takes.
No problem for the covers that have been deleted from me but sometimes they also delete my original posters and textless without a logical explanation. The problem that some users experience, is the inconsistency between the mods. Contacting the Moderators for any explanation is almost impossible, so I won't say anything more. I would like to know why my posters have not been uploaded for 2 days, I am still waiting for moderation. Maybe they're mad at me for complaining? I don't know, but no problem.
bye and have a good day